Tuesday, December 06, 2005

Blurred boundaries

When does a blog become a part of MSM? Or how do you differentiate between a blog and news portal? My definition of a blog is this - A blog is a webpage maintained by a individual or a group solely to disperse information related to the interests of the blogger(s) without any supervision of any sort. The blogger is both the financier, contributor and the editor of the information propagated through the blog.

But today, I read of a "blog portal that will be funded by investor's money"(via Kaps), my thoughts raced to this same definition from above. The entrepreneur has been throwing around terms like "revenue model" and sources close to the venture say that companies like Pepsi and Motorola are going to be sponsors. So what makes this "blog portal" different from, say, a portal like the online edition of TOI? TOI has a revenue model as well and a number of different companies advertise on there as well. If charging anywhere between 50 paise and a rupee for every click on their ads would make this new venture a "blog portal", then what is the USP over any other blog that subscribes to Google's Adsense?

But what is even more glaring is the byline for the blog: .... is the foremost blog representing the thoughts, aspirations, feeling and experiences of Indian youth. Most of the content is written by those in the 16-25 age group, with professional editors mentoring them to ensure professional quality material.

While the emphasis in the above text is mine, I am starting to wonder where the concept of blogs ends and MSM begins? When a similar case (i.e., blurring of boundaries) happens with any other subject, that would be taken as a positive, i.e. an attempt to bridge a gap, but when blogs seem to be the perfect antithesis to MSM, this seems to be a "I too" (grammatical error totally intentional) attempt by whoever is behind this attempt. And this thought comes to mind solely because of the presence of "professional editors" in this exercise. If the focus is to mentor future journos, then a un-monitored blog would be a perfect way to set them on that path! But this attempt seems to be something else. Is this the attempt of a tech-illiterate businessman to earn some money without ever knowing what he is dealing with?

28 comments:

thennavan said...

I think you pretty much summed up in the last line what it is :-)

Shankari said...

Went there today. Apart from the issues you raised, (GLAD u did!) it was pretty sweet and unremarkable bunch of kids...

Kaps said...

icarus prakash commented on my blog that they have copied their reviews from others....and I realized this myself after following the links provided by Prakash.

and what the hell is a blog PORTAL?

anantha said...

Kaps: Beats me...!

Shankari: Thats my point. By supervising, wouldn't we curtail creativity?

Thennavan: Ya.. I am waiting to see how they are gonna continue.. so its a wait and watch. But I see a contradiction in their definitions and though this sounds like high a funda concept, I basically think that they are trying to reinvent the wheel, whether or not they know it..

Balaji said...

"I too" (grammatical error totally intentional) - what about the other typos(?) in the post? :) et tu anti?!

anantha said...

BB: Thanx thalaiva... one of the pitfalls of having a really bad dialup connection (even here) is that you sometimes don't get a chance to do everything u want to. Nethu connection was a pain...and hence this embarrassment!

Prerona said...

Hey Anti, sorry for such a big delay in replying to your comment on my gmail post - i just saw it!

:(

listen, these links to the post page - you know how to make them conditional? that is, they should be there only if there is more (than the summary in the post page)

Balaji said...

thanx for taking that in the right spirit anti. yours is 1 of the blogs where the writing quality has been consistently high. so those typos kinda jumped out @ me :)

anantha said...

BB: Thanx :) The truth was out there. And in case, I know why it was caused :)

?! said...

"blogs seem to be the perfect antithesis to MSM" ...

MSM bashing is one of the topics that bloggers seem to relish. MSM is not necessarily the evil antiblog idea. Blogs are not necessarily rants of the obscure and unorganised.

MSM exists to provide a structured framework for dissemination of a general perception we call news. It funds it by advertising openly. And by covert ads called bias. Blogs dealing with news exist to point out a different or personal perception.

They are not on opposite sides of a moral or mental battlefield : they each occupy their own spaces. When Desipundit.com carries ads by Yahoo, is Yahoo funding the blog ? By several yardsticks, Yahoo can be defined as part of MSM. Does that mean Desipundit can no longer qualify to be part of the blogosphere ?

The gent is funding a blog. Paying people to write. Editing it. Its credibility would depend on content and perceived bias of the articles. If he'd kept shut and just put an ad for tech writers/content writers and started posting it, would it have been better ?

Just some random thoughts.

icarus prakash said...

random thoughts: MSM bashing is another thing. I admit that i dont subscribe to the views of most of the bloggers who indulge in bashing MSM. organized media and citizen's media ( read blogs) are two different animals and they can co-exist.

if a blog portal - whatever that means - gets funding, the historical event within quotes, WILL sure find a place in one of the supposedly leading business newspaper. So i personally dont have any comments the newsreport or it's editors.

But in this case, what amuses me is that the audacity with which, these so-called bloggers, get a domain name, register, cut and paste articles, get some dubiously sounding organization to fund, hire a PR man to plant news in MSM and finaly make us to write on them.

The only thing they chose to forget is that, google tool bar with a search tool is only few hundred kilobytes and is compatible with most of the browsers :-)

these kind of exploitations should be exposed.

anantha said...

?!: Understand where you are coming from. But this was not a anti-MSM rant. Not at all. This is a rant on "professional monitoring" of (what the site's owners/creaters describe) as "bloggers".

They are not on opposite sides of a moral or mental battlefield : they each occupy their own spaces.
Exactly. But I stand by my anti-thesis comment, because we have seen several cases where news-space has been sold and self-propagatory articles inserted in exchange for cash. So the boundaries bettween "advertisements" and news has blurred. And since most of people have been getting their news through the MSM, they have to put up with these so-called news articles that they don't need. But they do read them.
You might say that blogs are another form of advertisements, but atleast the consumer/reader has a choice. Several reasons - he/she does not pay for it and also a blog post is usually on one subject. And if that subject is not what the reader looks for, he might just close the window and get out.
DP carries ads from Yahoo, but Yahoo does not have any editorial control over DP. So unless Patrix and Co. hand over editorial control to the highest bidder who will impose editorial control, DP is and shall remain a blog.
So my definitions are this (am borrowing your words here)
The gent is funding a blog. Paying people to write. Editing it - MSM
The gent is funding a blog. Paying people to write and edit their own posts. - Blog

?! said...

Anti, this is getting semantic.

The people are CHOOSING to get their posts edited. If I pay an editor to edit, say, some poetry that I post, does it stop being MY post ? Some writing networks have paid/unpaid editorial help. Remains the author's work.They have the choice to get out if they don't like the revised version, right ? They stay, ergo it is their post.

Paying for a newspaper is not funding it. ( By a LONG shot. The price one pays for a paper wouldna get you the same quantity of white paper in Mumbai).Ads fund a paper. As far as choice is concerned, the consumer has a variety of newspapers to choose from. Blog post :(maybe) one subject. Blog : several posts. Newspaper article : (maybe) one subject. Several articles == a paper. Don't like an article, shut the page.
You pay directly to read a paper; you pay indirectly in terms of Cable TV charges to see BBC or Sun TV or Gemini.You do pay for reading a blog in terms of net access, just more indirectly.

Lotsa ads masqueradng as news.
Enough fakes masquerading as blog posts: IIPM's fake support network is a case in point.

Every media has an agenda. One's maybe overtly moneymaking. Other's might be more subtle money-oriented. Yet another's might be furtherance of a social/political point of view.

The point is, blogs == mostly unorganised media. MSM == organised biz model. Just as lack of organization is no guarantee of zero bias, an organized biz model is not necessarily slanted.

Since we rely on the media for news, we simply rely on our gut feel for perceived bias and try to read a few more sources to get a better picture.

Basically, I don't believe that blogs are an antithesis to MSM. They are two independent entities.

anantha said...

?!: The people are CHOOSING to get their posts edited.
I guess its the other way around. They are being chosen to get their posts edited.
If I pay an editor to edit, say, some poetry that I post, does it stop being MY post.
In that case it does not, since you have the option of accepting your editor's work. But if he is paying you, he's the final authority. Do you see the difference? I don't have anything to go against the your other points, well except your last statement. :)

?! said...

http://www.desipundit.com/2005/12/09/punishing-the-victim/

Where i am ranting, finding not so good similarities between MSM and blogs.

Paul88888 said...

We Wish You A Very Happy New Year!

Good Life certainly demands a good income and that is our mission. Our desire is to provide families worldwide great opportunities to increase their income so that their families can be well cared for, give their children a good education or the things they enjoy most in life. The following sites are among the best on the Internet. ACT NOW! Also feel free to pass on these great sites to friends and relatives. You will be blessed a lot more by blessing others!
1. The Rich Jerk - Stop Being a Pathetic Loser.
2. Affiliate Cash Vault - New fail-safe system virtually runs 100% on autopilot. Just set it and forget it!
3. Google Profits - How to Make Massive Profits Combining the Power of Google and CB.
4. Google Cash - Official Google Cash How to Earn Thousands Writing Google AdWords Part-Time updated w/ 24 videos.
5. BlogBlaster Submits To 2 Million Sites - Brand new advertising software submits to 2 million blogs!
6. Brand New Adwords Software - Become A Super Affiliate Overnight! Software Finds Most Profitable Search Terms And Products For You!
7. Instantly Increase Your Traffic & Sales - Instant Booster - Incredible Software increases your Income Instantly.
8. Fire Sale Profits - Discover the Secrets of Successful Fire Sales and How You Can Make A Fortune Selling Downloadable Products!
9. Easiest Way To Make $100+ A Day SwapClix - Instant Money Generator, Guaranteed Results, Work From Home Make Money Now! We Hide Your Affiliate Id! No Commision Stealing!
10. Process Instant Rebates Online - Make Money Online! Low Refunds.
11. The Lazy Pig - Convert $1 To $85 - Undisclosed Revolutionary 7 Step Adsense Marketing System.
12. AdBlaster Submits To 2,500,000 Sites - AdBlaster blasts to 2,500,000 Websites with just 1 click!
13. AdSense Gold-Your Fast Track To Profits - Triple your Ctr, skyrocket your Epc, track your clicks by search engine, referrer and more! Learn how to join the AdSense Elite.
14. 1stPromotion - Pro2 Mall & Portal - The Ultimate CB Mall & Affiliate Portal. The Only Mall That Gives You Total Control. Thousands Of Products, One Url.
15. The Google Ca$h Machine - Start Earning 15 Minutes from Now! Automatically.
16. The Article System - Content Generator - Instantly add targeted content to your website. Create pages that search engines will index to boost your traffic and profit!
17. Massive Targeted Traffic Guaranteed - Amazing Formula Allows You To Drive All The Targeted Website Traffic You Could Ever Possibly Want!
18. Google Adsense Secrets - Second Edition - Incredible Google Adsense secrets revealed by Pro who earns over $500/day - Breakthrough best-selling eBook - Instant download!
19. Make Big Money Taking Surveys Online - Get Paid $25.00-75.00 Per Survey Completed! High Conversions! Low Refunds!
20. Search Engine Cloaker (since 1995) - We are proud to help our customers achieve number 1 rankings in all engines for 10+ years.
21. domain name registration australia - It offers much of all the domain name registration australia related products.
22. Cash Income - More than doubling your income.
23. Top 10 Home Based Businesses - No website and no inventory needed.
24. Egold - Open a free egold account here!
25. Online Payment Commission - Earn 4% commission 6 levels deep from online payments.
26. Daily Cash Sites - Daily cash sites for sale.
27. Easy Website Templates - 5000+ easy website templates for selling any product, save you 100s of hours.
28. Email marketing Email 700,000,000 free plus 100% resale rights.
29. Bulk Email - Email millions now, promoting any products you wish.
30. Resell Rights - Get 6 millions people to invest $6 each, the maths is clear.
31. Bulk Email Marketing - Email 1000s of PayPal members daily for $12 per year.
32. Buy eGold - Among the cheapest rate on earth.
33. Top Business Opportunities - The best on offer, Act Now!
34. Family Income - Earn more for your family now.
35. Profitable Business Opportunities - Already profitable websites for sales at great discount.
36. Search Engine Submission - Drive search engine traffic to your website.
37. Domains - Cheap domains for many countries.
38. Best Web Hosting - The best web hosting services you can ever find and much more.
39. Auto Ad Submitter - Submit your ad on autopilot once and for all.
40. Website Submitter - Submit your sites to millions, fully automated.
41. Traffic Booster - Boost traffic to your site instantly.
42. SiteSell Website - Build websites that really sell.
43. Home Based Business - For a small tiny investment, you will be sharing in the billion-dollar online industries.
44. Domain Hosting Registries - Great site to get a good discount for your online store.
45. Netsuitestore - Among the greatest stores onlne.
46. Personal and Health care are equally important, bookmark these sites for your family:
47. Nutritional Supplements - Vitamin power nutritional supplements.
48. Native Remedies - The ultimate source of energy and native remedies in the world.
49. Herbal Supplements - Natural is the best.
50. Anti Aging - For the young at heart.
51. Diamonds - Diamonds for eternity.
52. Diamond Jewelry - The best diamond Jewelry in the world.
53. Earn High Income - Search for the best and the most desirable for yourself.
54. Increase My Income - Act Now! Don't delay.
55. Online Income Opportunities - It is endless but to succeed, you must act upon it.

Robert Campanile said...

Hello really enjoyed reading your blog/site about HomeBusiness and found quite a bit of great information and will bookmark your site so I don't miss out on anything in the future. Also if you would like MasterResaleRights to Hundreds of Niche Products worth $3000 for only $29.95 then go here http://www.incomecash.info and check it out! And thanks again for that great blog.

Paul88888 said...

You have generated a lot of interest in your blog. It does contain a great deal of information and discussion. If you have some spare time, do feel free to visite the following cheap domain registration site as it offers much of all the cheap domain registration related services.

Kim said...

From time to time we find a blog interesting enough to read. Yours is in that category.

My partner and I have this interesting viral marketing ebook tool. It is a cool and effective viral marketing ebook tool.

bloggggggs said...

You have generated a lot of interest in your blog. It contains a great deal of discussion. Feel free to surf the following sites domain host, domain name, domain reseller, au domain and free website!

Paul88888 said...

You have generated a lot of interest in your blog. It contains a great deal of discussion. Feel free to surf the following sites web hosting domain registration, domain name, domain reseller, au domain and free website!

bloggggggs said...

You have generated a lot of interest in your blog. It contains a great deal of discussion. Feel free to surf the following sites domain name registration and hosting, domain name, domain reseller, au domain and free website!

Anonymous said...

Hi, Your site looks real impressive. It must have taken you a lot of time and effort to make it this good. When you have some time you might like to check this out
http://www.urfortuneshere.com/recommend/amm.htm

James Baker said...

Hi, Fellow!I like your blog!
I just came across your blog and wanted to
drop you a note telling you how impressed I was with
the information you have posted here.
I have a domain names center
site. It pretty much covers domain names center related subjects.
Come and check it out if you get time :-)
Best regards!

James Baker said...

I just came across your blog and wanted to
drop you a note telling you, Friend, how impressed I was with it.
I give you my best wishes for your future endeavors.
If you have a moment, please visit my site:
domain names center
It covers domain names center related contents.
All the best!

Scott Arthur Edwards said...

Here it is... FREE advertising, FREE download. No cost to you! Get your FREE download NOW! Make money and get FREE advertising! This is a great program for you to take advantage of... Check this out now for FREE!

To find out more visit: homebusiness site. It successfully exposes FREE information covering traffic and homebusiness related stuff. Don't forget, FREE, FREE, FREE!!!

Scott Arthur Edwards said...

Dear friends, Now you can help yourself take advantage of the huge surpluses of FREE advertising in your spare time, in the comfort of your own home. Hook up NOW with this exiting program. Click here: FREE INFORMATION

Scott Arthur Edwards said...

Dear friend, Here is an opportunity for you that is taking over the internet. The compensation plan is second to none. The spill over will blow your mind and the educational products are of the highest quality. Knowledge is power and nobody can ever take that away from you. Join me in this business and see for yourself what you will be getting. Click here: FREE Information